Pensions in the Trenches: How Pension Spending is Affecting U.S. Local Government

Summary

Many experts argue that U.S. local governments are experiencing dramatic increases in their pension expenditures and that pension spending is crowding out government services. Others maintain that serious pension problems are limited to a few governments. This issue is important to both political scientists and policy practitioners, but no existing studies—nor the datasets they rely on— allow evaluation of the extent to which local pension expenditures are rising or whether pensions are affecting services.

This paper–authored by faculty director, Sarah Anzia–analyzes a new dataset of the annual pension expenditures of over 400 municipalities and counties from 2005 to 2016. Anzia finds that pension expenditures have risen almost everywhere, but there is significant variation in that growth. On average, local governments are not responding to rising pension spending by increasing revenue. They are instead shrinking their workforces, and that pattern is more pronounced in places with public-sector collective bargaining and tax and expenditure limits.

pensions image

Related Posts

As California grapples with a projected budget deficit of $22.5 billion for the upcoming fiscal year, state lawmakers are under immense pressure to balance the budget. This financial strain is...
Funding state-wide education isn’t cheap. But a well-funded early care and P-16 system has both direct benefits to students as well as indirect benefits to society. As we review impacts...
Read the full policy brief, which reviews the research evidence for lowering the voting age, California’s historical context, and predicted turnout rates for 17-year-olds. Using data from the Cooperative Election...
Governor Newsom’s revised K-12 budget could foreshadow future problems for CA schools   On May 12, Governor Newsom released an updated budget for 2023-24 fiscal year. The new budget proposal reflects...